Silicon Carbide vs. Aluminum Oxide Firepolish Comparison Test

Micrographs by Nikki O'Neill

Samples by Tony Smith and Steve Immerman

Aperture Pour Tutorial

Pattern Bar Tutorial

Photo Frame Tutorial

Floral Former Vase Tutorial

Wine Bottle Stopper Tutorial

Wire Mesh Melt Tutorial

Woven Bowl Tutorial

Links

Strip Cut Construction

Sandblaster Abrasives

Image 1

This is a sample of Bullseye clear glass. The left half has not been blasted, the right half has been blasted with 120 grit Silicon Carbide by Tony Smith and then firepolished  .

I believe that this demonstrates that a glass surface that is blasted with silicon carbide and firepolished, although acceptable to the naked eye, may not end up the same as a "virgin" surface.

SiC

Image 1

Close-up

Close up of photo above
Al2O3

Image 2

This sample was  Bullseye black,  blasted with 120 grit aluminum oxide, 20 psi. Firepolished to 1450 degrees. (White circles are frit place on the surface as  identification markers.)

 Nikki's observations:

"There wasn't much to see. Very few nicks and small fractures."

SiC
Image 3
Bullseye clear and black (non iridized) blasted with 200 grit silicon carbide, and fired with the blasted sides facing one another. This micrograph is focused in between the layers.
SiC
Image 3

Close-up

Close up of image 3.
SiC
Image 4 This sample has Bullseye iridized clear and iridized black. There is a design sandblasted with 220 grit Silicon carbide on each irid surface and they were fired to 1490 degrees,  with the irid sided facing. (The yellow frit was placed on this sample to help distinguish it from the others.)

Nikki notes: "Bubbles are trapped on all layers, and fewer are evident where only one layer was blasted."

SiC
Image 4

Close-up

Same sample as image 4. This is a view of the corner, where both top and bottom surfaces were blasted toward the top and right. Only one surface blasted bottom and left..
SiC
Image 5
Blasted with Silicon carbide. Not firepolished.
SiC
Image 6
Blasted with aluminum oxide. Not firepolished.
Al2O3
Image 7
Clear glass, two layers, top surface blasted with 120 grit Aluminum Oxide and firepolished at 1450 degrees.

 

Very few bubbles, nicks and fractures, except at the edge of the piece where there are more. The interface between the two clear layers is not discernable.

Al2O3a